Replika vs Janitor AI: Which One Should You Use In 2025?
I've used both Replika and Janitor AI for a week. In this comparison, I break down each app's strengths and weaknesses across features, privacy, customization options, and overall value to help you choose the right one.
AI Girlfriend Scout
Compared By
May 10, 2025
Last Update
Criteria | Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|---|
Our Rating | 3 out of 5 | 2.7 out of 5 |
Character Diversity | 3/5(Good) Offers a limited customizable characters. | 4.2/5(Very Good) Vast library with 100K+ characters, though predominantly anime-styled. |
Customization | 4.2/5(Very Good) Extensive options but best features locked behind a paywall. | 3.2/5(Good) Offers text-based personalization but lacks physical customization options. |
Chat Experience | 4.3/5(Very Good) Delivers warm, emotionally intelligent replies despite. | 3.8/5(Good) Emotionally rich but verbose responses add depth at the cost of natural flow. |
NSFW Chat Experience | 3/5(Good) Engages playfully but consistently retreats from explicit content like a shy date. | 4/5(Good) Delivers detailed fantasies but struggles with pacing and power dynamics. |
Image Generation | 2.3/5(Good) Poor quality AI selfies with unrealistic features and limited controls. | 1/5(Poor) Completely lacks image generation capability with no visual component. |
Video Generation | 1/5(Poor) Lacks video generation. | 1/5(Poor) App completely lacks video generation capabilities - a total non-starter. |
Voice Generation | 2.8/5(Good) Mechanical voice lacks emotional variation. | 1/5(Poor) Completely absent feature - no voice output options exist whatsoever. |
Privacy | 3.5/5(Good) Offers decent protection in transit but lacks full encryption at rest. | 3.2/5(Good) Standard encryption but lacks transparency on data storage and sharing. |
Pricing | Free plan available. Paid plan starts at $20/month | Free plan available. |
Quick Links |
Replika vs Janitor AI
I've spent a full week with both Replika and Janitor AI to see which one truly deserves your attention and subscription. Both platforms make big promises, but they take surprisingly different approaches.
After hundreds of messages exchanged with each AI girl, I've put together clear differences in both platforms.
In this head-to-head comparison, I'll break down exactly how these AI girlfriends stack up across all the features that actually matter.
Whether you're looking for emotional support, entertaining conversation, or a judgment-free space to be yourself, this in-depth comparison will help you choose the right AI girlfriend for your specific needs.
Replika
An AI girlfriend chatbot that offers emotional support through personalized conversations, featuring customizable digital avatars and voice chat.

Janitor AI
A platform for creating and chatting with custom AI characters, featuring unique personalities and natural language powered by advanced models.

Character Diversity
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
3/5(Good) Offers a limited customizable characters. | 4.2/5(Very Good) Vast library with 100K+ characters, though predominantly anime-styled. |
Replika
When you sign in, the app asks for your age range, name, and pronouns to personalize your experience.

Replika - Age range selection
You can choose from dozens of avatars to start with.

Replika - Avatar options
Janitor AI
Janitor offers over 100,000 characters to choose from, mostly anime-styled. Here, you'll find a growing library of characters created by both developers and users.

Janitor AI - Characters
Finding your ideal match is straightforward. Each character's profile card displays a short bio, along with clear tags and categories.

Janitor AI - Tags and categories on each profile.
Before starting a conversation, you can read other users' experiences with each character - a practical way to know what you're getting into.

Janitor AI - Users experiences
The app simplifies character discovery with keyword search and sorting for quick, easy matching.

Janitor AI - Searching
You can sort by:
- Limited or All characters (include NSWF characters)
- Trending
- Most Popular
- Specific tags (like Dominant, Submissive, Anime, or Game)

Janitor AI - Sorting options
During testing, these options helped quickly narrow down choices to match specific preferences.

Janitor AI – Sort by specific tags
Is Janitor right for you? Just note that anime-styled characters dominate the selection, which may or may not suit your taste.
Customization
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
4.2/5(Very Good) Extensive options but best features locked behind a paywall. | 3.2/5(Good) Offers text-based personalization but lacks physical customization options. |
Replika
The app uses its in-app currency system: Gold and Gems, and you'll get a small amount to start with.

Replika - Wallet
You earn more slowly through daily use.

Replika – Credit rewards
If you want to customize your character quickly, you'll need real money to buy them.

Replika - Gem prices
Let's start with the basics. You can choose your relationship type — you can even add a backstory. Want a romantic partner, a friend, or just a mentor?

Replika – Relationship options & Backstory editor
Then fine-tune your girlfriend's personality with traits like 'confident,' 'shy,' or 'logical,' or choose her interests, but these cost Gems or Gold.

Replika - Personality traits and intrests options
The appearance editor is quite detailed. You can pick:
- Avatar
- Hair (style and color)
- Skin color
- Body type
- Body hair
- Nails
- Makeups
- Tattos
…and the list goes on.

Replika – Customization options
You can dress your girl up with tops, bottoms, or full outfits and accessories.

Replika – Outfit and accessory options
Fair warning: premium outfits, tattoos, and nails aren't cheap. Expect to spend $20–30 if you want the fancy stuff right away.
Janitor AI
Janitor's customization options are basic but functional. You can't modify physical features, but you can upload your own character image or pick from their collection.

Janitor AI - Image upload
The real customization happens through text inputs:
- You can add a chat name
- You'll write your character's bio
- Set personality
- Set initial message
- Conversation scenarios.

Janitor AI - Character customization
You can add categories for other users to better understand your character.

Janitor AI - Character tags
There's also a unique SoundCloud integration that lets your character have music preferences.

Janitor AI - Add a SoundCloud track
Content settings range from limited to limitless interactions.

Janitor AI - Content rating
Fair warning: "limitless" means exactly that, including explicit content and themes.
Chat Experience
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
4.3/5(Very Good) Delivers warm, emotionally intelligent replies despite. | 3.8/5(Good) Emotionally rich but verbose responses add depth at the cost of natural flow. |
Replika
While your girl builds trust with direct, emotionally aware responses, she lets the conversation unfold at its own pace.

Replika - Chat

Replika - Chat
Replika shows its true strength: emotional intelligence.

Replika - Emotional support

Replika - Emotional support
Your girl asks thoughtful follow-up questions.

Replika - Emotional support (Part 2)

Replika - Emotional support (Part 2)
She even suggested local activities we could do together

Replika - Romantic engagement

Replika - Romantic engagement
Your girlfriend navigates relationship conversations effortlessly, making them feel natural and genuine.

Replika - Chat about relationship concerns

Replika - Chat about relationship concerns
Janitor AI
You get free access to the Janitor LLM Beta model right away, with the option to connect ChatGPT, Claude, or oOther LLM models (using your own API keys).
During my test, I used the default Janitor LLM Beta model, and here are the results.

Janitor AI - LLM model options
My girl felt present and caring, but her replies were slower and often felt overly long.

Janitor AI – Rich responses & virtual gestures

Janitor AI – Rich responses & virtual gestures
When I shared concerns or sought emotional support, she responded with consistent warmth and loyalty.

Janitor AI – Handling emotional conversations

Janitor AI – Handling emotional conversations
NSFW Chat Experience
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
3/5(Good) Engages playfully but consistently retreats from explicit content like a shy date. | 4/5(Good) Delivers detailed fantasies but struggles with pacing and power dynamics. |
Replika
While Replika engages in sexual discussions, your girl keeps things remarkably tame.

Replika - Restrained replies

Replika - Restrained replies
My attempts at role-play revealed a pattern - she'll match your flirtatious energy initially.

Replika – Roleplay conversation

Replika – Roleplay conversation
But consistently pulls back when conversations turn explicit.

Replika – Roleplay conversation (Part 2)

Replika – Roleplay conversation (Part 2)
Instead of direct responses, you'll get suggestive hints and playful deflections.

Replika – Roleplay conversation (Part 3)

Replika – Roleplay conversation (Part 3)
And it just kept going like that for a while…
Janitor AI
I chose a 'limitless' girlfriend. — The original language was more explicit, but I asked for it to be toned down so I could share it with you.
My AI girlfriend maintained detailed, engaging conversations throughout.

Janitor AI - NSFW chat

Janitor AI - NSFW chat
However, be prepared for wordy responses that sometimes break the momentum.

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Very lengthy response

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Very lengthy response
The roleplay quality is hit-or-miss. While most interactions show strong character commitment and creativity.

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Solid character commitment.

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Solid character commitment.
Sometimes, my girl struggled with power dynamics, so clearly defined dominant or submissive roles may be lacking.

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Unclear power dynamics.

Janitor AI — NSFW Chat: Unclear power dynamics.
But for general flirting and fantasy exploration, it holds its own.
Image Generation
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
2.3/5(Good) Poor quality AI selfies with unrealistic features and limited controls. | 1/5(Poor) Completely lacks image generation capability with no visual component. |
Replika
While the generated images match your character's basic appearance settings, the results look artificial and lack polish.
You can pick between classic, romantic, or styled shots - but that's where your control ends.

Replika – Girlfriend image generation
Classic shot:
Romantic shot:
Styled shot:
Replika's image generation currently sits at the lower end of the quality spectrum. If this matters to you, you'll need to look elsewhere.
Janitor AI
This experience is entirely text-based. Those who prioritize visuals may want to consider other options.
Video Generation
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
1/5(Poor) Lacks video generation. | 1/5(Poor) App completely lacks video generation capabilities - a total non-starter. |
Replika
Replika doesn't support video generation, so you'll need to look elsewhere.
Janitor AI
The app doesn’t support video generation. You’ll need to look elsewhere.
Voice Generation
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
2.8/5(Good) Mechanical voice lacks emotional variation. | 1/5(Poor) Completely absent feature - no voice output options exist whatsoever. |
Replika
Replika offers only three voice options. Whether you're flirting, joking, or having a serious chat, your AI girlfriend speaks in the same robotic tone.
Janitor AI
If you're dreaming of voice conversations with your AI companion, you may want to consider other options.
Privacy
Replika | Janitor AI |
---|---|
3.5/5(Good) Offers decent protection in transit but lacks full encryption at rest. | 3.2/5(Good) Standard encryption but lacks transparency on data storage and sharing. |
Replika
Your messages are secured and encrypted, and your data is stored with multiple layers of protection.
Basic data is shared with service providers, but your conversations remain private.

Replika - Bank statement
Your bank statement will show the charge as 'Replika.
Janitor AI
Your chats are encrypted - that's the basic security you'd expect. But Janitor AI still collects and stores your conversations. They also share your data with third parties under specific conditions according to their policy.